top of page
Search

How to Verify a Roofer's References and Past Work: What Every Homeowner Should Check Before Hiring

Nov 12
6 min read

Choosing a roofing contractor is a big decision. Your roof protects your home, your belongings and everything underneath it. With so many roofing companies advertising their services, how do you know which contractor will actually deliver quality workmanship?

One of the best ways to find out is by looking at their previous work and speaking with homeowners who have hired them.

A professional-looking website and a few impressive advertisements don't necessarily tell you how a roofing company operates once the job begins. Checking references, reviewing completed projects and researching customer experiences can help you separate experienced professionals from contractors who may not live up to their promises.

At Ace 1 Quality Roofing, Siding & Eavestroughs, we believe homeowners should feel confident about the company they hire. Here are some important ways to verify a roofer's references and past work before signing a contract.

1. Ask for References From Previous Customers

A reputable roofing contractor should be able to provide references or direct you to genuine customer feedback.

Don't be afraid to ask for contact information for homeowners who have recently completed similar roofing projects.

When speaking with previous customers, consider asking:

  • Was the roofing project completed on schedule?

  • Did the contractor communicate throughout the installation?

  • Was the crew professional and respectful of your property?

  • Was the job site cleaned up properly?

  • Were there any unexpected costs?

  • Were you satisfied with the finished roof?

  • Would you hire the company again?

These questions can reveal a lot more than simply asking whether someone liked their new roof.

If possible, speak with customers who had similar roofing materials, roof designs or project requirements.

2. Look at Photos of Completed Roofing Projects

Photos are one of the easiest ways to evaluate a roofing company's previous work.

However, don't just look at attractive pictures of finished roofs. Pay attention to the quality of the installation.

Look for:

  • Straight and consistent shingle lines.

  • Clean ridge caps and roof edges.

  • Properly finished valleys.

  • Neat flashing around chimneys and skylights.

  • Professional detailing around roof penetrations.

  • Clean eaves and surrounding exterior finishes.

A quality roofing installation is about more than how the roof looks from the street. The smaller details often make the biggest difference.

Ask whether the photos belong to the contractor and whether they represent projects completed by their own crews.

3. Check Google Reviews and Online Reputation

Online reviews can provide valuable insight into how a roofing company treats its customers.

Start by researching the contractor's Google Business Profile.

Look beyond the overall star rating and read the actual reviews.

Pay attention to:

  • How many reviews the company has.

  • Whether reviews are spread over several years.

  • Whether customers mention specific roofing projects.

  • How the company responds to positive and negative feedback.

  • Whether customers consistently mention communication, cleanliness and workmanship.

A company with a strong history of genuine customer feedback can provide additional confidence when making your decision.

Remember that reviews are only one part of your research. Always consider references, insurance and the actual scope of the roofing estimate as well.

4. Ask to See Similar Roofing Projects

Not every roofing project is the same.

A contractor who primarily installs basic asphalt shingles may not have the same experience with complex roof designs, metal roofing, skylights or specialized ventilation systems.

Ask to see examples of projects similar to yours.

For example:

  • Asphalt shingle roof replacements.

  • Metal roofing installations.

  • Three-storey homes.

  • Complex rooflines and valleys.

  • Skylight installations.

  • Storm and wind damage repairs.

  • Roofing projects involving ventilation upgrades.

This helps you understand whether the contractor has the experience needed for your particular home.

5. Visit a Recently Completed Roofing Project

If the contractor has recently completed a project nearby, ask whether you can view the finished roof from the ground.

Seeing a completed project in person can give you a better understanding of the company's workmanship and attention to detail.

You can look at the overall appearance, roofline consistency, flashing details and cleanup around the property.

Always obtain the homeowner's permission before entering private property or taking a closer look.

6. Check How Long the Roofing Company Has Been Operating

Experience matters in the roofing industry.

A company with an established history may have developed valuable experience handling different roof designs, materials, weather conditions and installation challenges.

Research the company's:

  • Years in business.

  • Business registration and contact information.

  • Local service history.

  • Previous roofing projects.

  • Manufacturer certifications.

  • Customer reviews and references.

Keep in mind that years in business alone don't guarantee quality. A newer company can also have experienced installers, so consider the qualifications and track record of the actual people doing the work.

7. Look for Manufacturer Certifications

Another way to evaluate a roofing contractor is by checking whether they have manufacturer certifications.

Some roofing manufacturers offer contractor programs that recognize installers who meet specific program requirements.

These certifications can demonstrate familiarity with particular roofing products and installation requirements.

For example, Ace 1 Quality Roofing is proud to be a Malarkey Certified Pro Contractor.

We believe in offering homeowners quality roofing products and professional installation, with a focus on the details that help protect their homes.

When comparing contractors, ask what certifications they hold and whether those credentials can be verified with the manufacturer.

8. Watch for Fake Reviews and Misleading Portfolio Photos

Unfortunately, not every roofing company's online reputation accurately represents its work.

There are a few warning signs homeowners should watch for:

  • A large number of reviews appearing within a very short period.

  • Reviews that contain almost identical wording.

  • Photos that appear on multiple unrelated roofing websites.

  • Contractors who cannot explain where their project photos were taken.

  • References that cannot be independently verified.

  • Companies that refuse to provide examples of previous work.

Don't automatically assume something is wrong, but take the time to verify what you're being shown.

A trustworthy contractor should have no problem discussing their previous projects.

9. Compare References Alongside Your Roofing Estimate

Even if a roofing company has excellent reviews, you should still compare the details of its estimate.

Make sure you're evaluating the complete roofing system, not just the final price.

Your estimate should clearly identify:

  • Shingle manufacturer and product line.

  • Ice and water shield.

  • Underlayment.

  • Flashing and drip edge.

  • Roof ventilation.

  • Plywood replacement pricing.

  • Labour and installation details.

  • Cleanup and disposal.

  • Manufacturer and workmanship warranties.

A contractor's previous work and customer references should support the quality they're promising in their estimate.

10. Ask the Contractor Directly: Why Should I Choose Your Company?

This is a simple question that can tell you a lot.

A professional roofing contractor should be able to explain what separates their company from the competition.

Look for answers that go beyond simply saying they offer the cheapest prices.

Consider whether they emphasize:

  • Quality materials.

  • Experienced installers.

  • Proper installation procedures.

  • Attention to detail.

  • Insurance and workplace safety.

  • Clear communication.

  • Written warranties.

  • Customer satisfaction.

The best roofing company isn't necessarily the cheapest or the one with the biggest advertising budget. It's the company that can demonstrate the quality and professionalism it promises.

Roofing Contractor Verification Checklist

Before signing your next roofing agreement, make sure you've completed these important steps:

  • Asked for previous customer references.

  • Reviewed genuine Google customer feedback.

  • Looked at photos of completed projects.

  • Verified that project photos belong to the contractor.

  • Asked about similar roofing installations.

  • Checked business history and credentials.

  • Verified manufacturer certifications.

  • Requested proof of liability insurance.

  • Checked applicable WSIB coverage and clearance.

  • Reviewed the roofing estimate and written warranty.

Taking a little extra time to research your contractor can help prevent expensive mistakes.

Why Homeowners Choose Ace 1 Quality Roofing

At Ace 1 Quality Roofing, Siding & Eavestroughs, we understand that homeowners are trusting us with one of their biggest investments.

We take pride in our workmanship, customer relationships and attention to the details that matter.

From proper ice and water shield installation and wrapping roof penetrations to seamless venting solutions beneath shingles, we believe quality roofing starts with doing things right.

As a Malarkey Certified Pro Contractor, we're proud to offer quality roofing products and professional installation.

We proudly serve homeowners throughout the Niagara Region, including:

St. Catharines, Niagara Falls, Welland, Thorold, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Fort Erie, Grimsby, Lincoln, Fonthill, Port Colborne and surrounding communities.

Whether you're considering a complete roof replacement, metal roofing, roof repairs or a full exterior upgrade, our goal is to provide quality workmanship and an experience homeowners can feel confident about.

Don't just take a roofer's word for it. Check their work. Verify their reputation. Make an informed decision.

Ready to Discuss Your Roofing Project?

Contact Ace 1 Quality Roofing, Siding & Eavestroughs to discuss your next project and request a roofing estimate.

ACE 1 QUALITY ROOFING – COMPLETE HOME EXTERIORS.https://g.page/r/Cd3fSANT2a2qEAE/review

 
 
 

Comments


815188582185424ba0efa906b9e48a02--vinyl-siding-home-projects_edited_edited_edited_edited.j
Ace 1 Quality Roofing, Siding & Eavestroughs GAF Certified
5 star reviews Ace 1 Quality Roofing, Siding & Eavestroughs GAF Certified
Ace 1 Quality Roofing Inc - Certified Pro Contractor Certificate
Niagara Board of trade and Commerce
Financeit
Ace 1 Quality Roofing | Siding & Eavestroughs is IKO Certified Pro Contractor
velux-logo.jpg
Follow us on Social Media!
  • X
  • TikTok
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube

©2024 by Ace1qualityroofing.com. Proudly created by Your Niagara Toolbox

bottom of page